Are these guys Hall of Famers?

1. Antonio Tarver
2. Winky Wright
3. Chris Byrd

No.

Winky is the closest but he isn't HOF worthy in my view.

lol NO
well i mean at least i hope not, but then i remember that dan rafael votes and he once said he would not only vote for gatti but also for.....CASAMAYOR!!!!!!!

I'd go no on all 3, but Tarver would be the closest.

He was the first guy to legitimately beat Roy Jones. A lot of fighters are in the Hall based on one huge win and that was up there. Sprinkle in his other good wins and he actually has a pretty good case. Especially with guys like McGuigan, Norris, and those level guys in there.

No.

No.

Winky has a shot, he was the first guy to unify the Jr Middleweight division in ages.

ScottLevinson wrote:I'd go no on all 3, but Tarver would be the closest.

He was the first guy to legitimately beat Roy Jones. A lot of fighters are in the Hall based on one huge win and that was up there. Sprinkle in his other good wins and he actually has a pretty good case. Especially with guys like McGuigan, Norris, and those level guys in there.

+1

Winky has more HOF wins.

Ali wrote:Winky has more HOF wins.

Mosley and Tito

Tarver's KO of Roy alone trumps anything Winky did

gomez1012 wrote:

Ali wrote:Winky has more HOF wins.

Mosley and Tito

Tarver's KO of Roy alone trumps anything Winky did

Tarver's was more shocking, but Winky absolutely dominated both men.

Plus Mosley went on to beat other top guys.

Put it this way, Tarver's wins much more significant than Winky's resume

I have Winky above Tarver also but I am not in love with either resume. Both 1 division legit champs with a small bit of work outside that division. Too bad Winky turned down the Taylor rematch for 5 million or his resume would far exceed Tarver's and probably be HOF worthy.

Hell no...fuck no.

1. No
2. No
3. No