Robert Guerrero and Adrian Broner in Rings P4P rankings

Broner is rated #5 and Guerrero is Rated #10. Does anyone agree with these guys being put on this list after beating mediocre opponents in their last fights?

no

*CoughsGoldenBoyCoughs*

I wish Grant was still around so he can defend his precious magazine.

I think Guerrero was/is knocking on the door to the top 10 but I personally wouldn't have him in. Now Broner has literally one good win. It is a very good win for a young gun and should put him on everyone's map but it should only get him highly rated at 135. That is all the win should do. If he takes out Burns and Gamboa (assuming Gamboa looks better than he did), then I can see Broner included by biased people. Right now it is a tragedy.

UBeeg9cats wrote:I think Guerrero was/is knocking on the door to the top 10 but I personally wouldn't have him in. Now Broner has literally one good win. It is a very good win for a young gun and should put him on everyone's map but it should only get him highly rated at 135. That is all the win should do. If he takes out Burns and Gamboa (assuming Gamboa looks better than he did), then I can see Broner included by biased people. Right now it is a tragedy.

..nice post.i guess abner mares gets no respect from ring.maybe because he isnt flashy but still come on.

According to Douglas, this is down to chuck giampa, the retired judge apparently is the ring's chairman of p4p rankings committee. Jokes

dougie fisher said in his mailbag on ringtv.com he hated the fact that Broner was ranked so high. He also said while he doesn't hate the fact that RG was number 10, there were more deserving guys.

dbudge wrote:According to Douglas, this is down to chuck giampa, the retired judge apparently is the ring's chairman of p4p rankings committee. Jokes

damn you. you beat me to it. I was making a 2nd post about Dougie Fisher's mailbag comments right when you did.

captainanddew wrote:

dbudge wrote:According to Douglas, this is down to chuck giampa, the retired judge apparently is the ring's chairman of p4p rankings committee. Jokes

damn you. you beat me to it. I was making a 2nd post about Dougie Fisher's mailbag comments right when you did.

Like a bullet..